09

Mar

Are your comments killing you?

Posted by stuart as blog commenting, blogging, blog

Not the comments on your blog, the comments you leave on other blogs.

There’s been a bit of talk in the Internet Marketing sphere of late about personal branding. Personally, I tend to subscribe to the SlightlyShady view that it’s all a bit of a wank, but we do need to be aware of the image we’re portraying to the wider world.

It’s a well known fact that I don’t spend a lot of time commenting on other blogs (sorry to my online friends, I do love you all, really!). I’m sure if I could find the time I could increase my readership/feedcount/alexa rank or whatever other metric you’d like to think of. One thing I do when I do comment on blogs (not always successfully)  is to portray a sense of intelligence and thoughtfulness.

Think about this for a minute. If you’re reading someone else’s blog, and you come across a comment like this:

LOL, good info here. loved reading this post.

Are you likely to follow the link to have a look at that blog?

I didn’t think so. However, if you read an insightful comment, maybe a bit witty, something that someone has actually put a bit of thought into, you’re much more likely to follow the link and take a look at the blog of the person who left the comment.

So spell check your comments, read them through one more time before hitting the “Post” button, and ask yourself what this comment says to someone who’s never heard of you or your blog before.

3 comments so far

I can understand the concept of what you are saying. But, sometimes blog comments are just quick gestures of a pat on the back or nod of approval. They don’t always need to be a deep analysis of the current topic, argumentative or congratulatory discourse. That said, I do tend to agree with you - comments generally be thoughtful enough to make other readers go hrmmm… if they’re sharp enough to post THAT comment, I bet their site is full of interesting reading!

I’m a bit of a chronic lurker as well - I also tend to speak my mind when I do post, and I know in my own experience I hate when a flame war develops in a comment thread. On the other hand, it can liven things up I suppose. Pluses and minuses to just about everything I guess.

When I was younger I read some blog and commented, I did for achieving some useful backlinks. But when I am older now, I read a blog and I really think about it, so I can learn something from it and then I am sharing my ideas in comment if it is followed, thanks, if not don’t mind.

Leave a Comment:

Name (required)
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
Message